Shakespeare in the Kitchen: Experiencing Renaissance Culture with Students Today

Marissa Nicosia is a scholar, writer, and cook. She is Professor of Renaissance Literature at The Pennsylvania State University–Abington College, where she teaches courses on English drama and poetry, food history and recipe manuscripts, and (digital) humanities.

William Shakespeare’s Othello is a play about appetites. It may not include splendid scenes of royal feasting or rowdy gatherings, but Shakespeare uses the language of carousing, drunkenness, and potations, as well as ripening, dishes, meat, and gorging, to describe a whole spectrum of desires. From ardent love to jealous rage, the language of food and appetite suffuses the tragic plot. When I teach Othello, I use Renaissance recipes to dive deep into the appetitive landscape of Shakespeare’s tragedy. By studying, cooking, and tasting these recipes, students gain a deeper and embodied understanding of culinary and medicinal cultures in Shakespeare’s England.

Our classroom inquiry includes close reading of Shakespeare’s language, transcribing primary source recipes, and experimental cookery, all with a focus on Desdemona’s strawberry-patterned handkerchief. It was Othello’s first gift to his beloved, and the cloth has a potent, magical backstory. Iago’s scheme to drive Othello into a jealous rage with accusations of Desdemona’s infidelity hinges on her loss of this handkerchief. Many scholars have written extensively about this handkerchief, and deciding how to stage this iconic prop is a decision that all productions of Othello have to make. My research on the play, and this lesson, considers the strawberries woven into the cloth and their connection to the real wild and garden strawberries that Shakespeare and his contemporaries knew and ate. Indeed, strawberries were thought to have many healthful properties, especially for calming jealous rage and hot tempers.

We begin a class on Othello, strawberries, and recipe cultures by analyzing moments in the play where the handkerchief is discussed in detail. We learn from Iago that the handkerchief is spotted with strawberries, and Othello provides an account of the handkerchief’s history (3.3.431). Woven in a strawberry black-work pattern from magical threads that have been dyed a dark brown color— “in mummy, which the skillful / Conserved of maidens’ hearts”—the handkerchief is steeped in cannibalistic medicines and exoticizing charms that seem poised to cure Othello’s jealousy and return the couple to nuptial bliss (3.4.71–72). Indeed, Othello’s mother was given this handkerchief by a “charmer” who promised her that while she carried the handkerchief, “’Twould make her amiable, and subdue my father / Entirely to her love” or rather magically preserve marital harmony (3.4.54, 56–57). Othello’s mother gave him this handkerchief on her deathbed with instructions to give it to his wife, and now the handkerchief, it seems, is the only thing that will restore harmony between Desdemona and Othello.

We then turn to a recipe for strawberry preserves from a late-sixteenth-century-manuscript: “To make concervay strawberrs.” Students often struggle at first with the unfamiliar style of Renaissance cursive (called Secretary Hand), but we work letter by letter, word by word, line by line, through the short paragraph. The recipe intends to “conserve” short-lived strawberries using the preservative power of honey or sugar and, in turn, preserve the health of anyone who consumes it.

To make concervay strawberrs
Take a quart of strawberres pike them cleane
and washe them boile them over a soft fiar & streane
them and put as much suger as the weght of them
and boile them agayne til thei be incorporated then
put it in glasses the vertue of this is good against
a hote liver or hote burninge of the ague stomake or
in the fervent heate of an agues some make them
of cleare suger some of hony clarified some with
hony and suger to gether honye is more holsom
though it be not so tothesom. (MS Codex 823, 35v)

Students first note that the recipe is a narrative paragraph that brings together ingredients and methods, as was typical of the period but different from recipe formats today. I ask the students how they would approach cooking this recipe. We agree that we would need a heat source, a pot, a cullender, measuring cups, a spoon for stirring, and a jar to hold the finished conserve. The recipe calls for strawberries, water, and either honey or sugar. Since none of these ingredients is quite the same today—for example, farms grow and sell a completely different strawberry cultivar—we ponder what we might taste by making the recipe now and what we might miss.

I supply the materials and ingredients, we begin to cook, and everyone takes a turn stirring, measuring, mashing. We learn that the smell of cooking strawberries is intoxicating, even more so when honey is stirred into them. We wait patiently for the jam to set, to part cleanly when the spoon is run along the bottom of the pan. Then everyone has a taste and shares their reactions: sweet but not too sweet; sweet but floral sweet; pure strawberry flavor; a food that makes me happy.

As we savor the honey-sweetened strawberry preserves we discuss the final sentences of the recipe, which describe its “vertue.” “To make concervay strawberrs” concludes with a medicinal efficacy note, which students tend to find surprising as they are not used to thinking about the health benefits of eating strawberry jam. In Shakespeare’s England, humoral theory was used to diagnose illnesses and to describe a person’s emotional state. The balance of the four humors—yellow bile, black bile, phlegm, and blood—was thought to govern bodily and mental health, and this balance could be impacted by diet, among other factors. One element of humoral thinking (geohumoralism) contended that individual temperament was determined by country and climate of origin, and Shakespeare draws on this idea when he describes Othello’s swift, jealous overreaction to Iago’s insinuations of Desdemona’s infidelity.

The virtues of this recipe for strawberry preserves draw on this same medical, proto-psychological, and dietary framework. The strawberry conserve will “conserve” the health of the person who eats it, whom we might now imagine as possibly a patient and not simply someone eating jam and bread. The preserves will calm heat, anger, and fever by altering a person’s humors. Moreover, the interplay of local English strawberries from the garden or the field and local honey (wholesome, beneficial, local) or imported sugar (toothsome, sweeter, exotic, produced by the labor of enslaved Africans on the other side of the Atlantic) will dictate the efficacy of the conserve. Using honey will be more medicinal, but using sugar will make the preserve sweeter. Students do note that the honey-sweetened preserve is not as sweet as the strawberry jams that they are accustomed to eating.

When we return to our discussion of Othello we have learned that not only are there possible cures for Othello’s jealous rage (strawberries, preserves made from them), but that Shakespeare has pointed us to these cures in his description of Desdemona’s handkerchief. Our discussion of the play’s appetitive rhetoric is deepened by the new understanding of humoral theory and strawberries that we have developed through reading and preparing a recipe. And as they reflect on this exercise students often say that Shakespeare’s works and his era feel closer, somehow, after this experience. By cooking, a mundane household activity both in the  Renaissance and today, students connect to past lives, past practices, past tastes that are simultaneously familiar and unfamiliar. Although this activity is predicated on access to high-quality digital images of Renaissance cookery manuscripts (and innumerable additional digital technologies), hands-on lessons like this one are a welcome opportunity for students to slow down, think about texts deeply by following their instructions and interpreting their meaning, and tasting flavors from the past.

Start your cooking journey! Explore more of Marissa’s recipes here and learn more about the new Norton Critical Edition of Othello, The Norton Shakespeare, and Norton Literature here.

Further Reading

Ambereen Dadabhoy, Shakespeare through Islamic Worlds (Routledge, 2024).

Miriam Jacobson, “Mummy in English and European Culture and Imagination,” Routledge Resources Online – The Renaissance World, eds. Kristen Poole and Wendy B. Hyman (Routledge, 2024).

MS Codex 823, 35v, Kislak Center for Special Collections, Rare Books and Manuscripts, University of Pennsylvania.

Marissa Nicosia, Shakespeare in the Kitchen (Routledge, 2026).

Marissa Nicosia, Cooking in the Archives (www.rarecooking.com).

Gitanjali G. Shahani, Tasting Difference: Food, Race, and Cultural Encounters in Early Modern Literature (Cornell University Press, 2020).

William Shakespeare, Othello in The Norton Shakespeare, 2nd ed., eds. Stephen Greenblatt et al. (Norton, 2016).

Ian Smith, “Othello’s Black Handkerchief,” Shakespeare Quarterly 64, no. 1 (2013): 1–25.

MEET THE AUTHOR

Image Credit: Marissa Nicosia

Marissa Nicosia is a scholar, writer, and cook. She is Professor of Renaissance Literature at The Pennsylvania State University–Abington College, where she teaches courses on English drama and poetry, food history and recipe manuscripts, and (digital) humanities. Marissa is the author of Shakespeare in the Kitchen (Routledge, 2026) and Imagining Time in the English Chronicle Play: Historical Futures, 1590–1660 (Oxford University Press, 2023). She runs the public history website Cooking in the Archives. 

Leave a Reply